Skip to main content

Table 6 Cross-program practices of SUDPs (N=241) and BIPs (N=235)

From: Addressing substance abuse and violence in substance use disorder treatment and batterer intervention programs

 

SUDPs

BIPs

X2

Service Centralization

(% yes, N)

(% yes, N)

 

To obtain help for both problems, potential clients can:

   

 Call only one phone number

56.8 (137)

45.5 (107)

5.39*

 Complete only one set of intake procedures

26.0 (63)

24.6 (58)

.10

 Obtain both at a single location

32.9 (79)

46.6 (110)

8.88**

 Have their program records shared with another of the cross type

20.6 (50)

23.0 (54)

.40

Program has arrangements with another program to refer clients to:

 Of the same type

2.9 (7)

3.4 (8)

.09

 Of the cross type

17.8 (43)

21.3 (50)

.89

 Of programs that have arrangements with the cross type (N=93; 43 SUDPs, 50 BIPs):

 Formal arrangement

3.8

12.1

2.78

 Informal arrangement

61.5

47.0

2.49

Staff Training

Direct care staff are informed about addressing cross problem:

  

29.10***

 All

54.0 (130)

79.3 (186)

 

 Some

24.5 (59)

14.5 (34)

 

 None

21.5 (52)

6.2 (15)

 

Direct care staff’s training in cross problem:

  

86.90***

 All are required to have formal training

12.9 (31)

45.4 (107)

 

 Some (certain positions) required to have formal training

24.1 (58)

23.8 (56)

 

 Some have informal training

32.3 (78)

24.7 (58)

 

 No staff members have formal or informal training

30.6 (74)

6.2 (15)

 

Treatment Integration

Program philosophy of best way to serve clients with both problems:

Help for both problems should be obtained at the same time, but in separate treatment programs

60.2 (145)

56.5 (133)

.64

Help for both problems should be integrated into one treatment program

31.0 (75)

29.7 (70)

.09

Substance abuse treatment should be completed first, followed by batterer intervention or anger management

9.7 (23)

19.0 (45)

7.87**

Batterer intervention or anger management should be completed first, followed by substance abuse treatment

.5 (1)

.4 (1)

.00

Potential clients seeking help for both problems:

  

21.72***

Are permitted to obtain cross help while in this program

61.0 (147)

72.8 (171)

 

No usual practice; depends on client and staff member

33.5 (81)

22.4 (53)

 

Should complete this program before obtaining cross help

4.6 (11)

.4 (1)

 

Must obtain cross help before this program

.9 (2)

4.4 (10)

 

Would more linkages, cooperation between SUDP and BIP communities benefit your clients?

  

9.26*

Definitely no

1.7 (4)

0 (0)

 

Probably no

5.2 (12)

5.6 (13)

 

Probably yes

47.2 (114)

39.2 (92)

 

Definitely yes

45.9

45.9 (111)

55.2 (130)

Barriers to your program being linked and cooperating with the cross type of program:

Differences in treatment philosophy between communities

9.9 (24)

12.9 (30)

1.02

Lack of substance abuse treatment training in BIPs

24.2 (58)

16.3 (38)

4.44*

Lack of batterer intervention training in SUDPs

36.3 (87)

23.6 (55)

8.84**

Lack of cross type of program in this area

19.3 (47)

9.0 (21)

10.12***

SUDPs not reimbursed for batterer intervention

31.8 (76)

15.0 (35)

18.32***

BIPs not reimbursed for substance abuse

10.8 (26)

29.2 (69)

24.89***

SUDPs and BIPs compete for clients

4.0 (10)

9.0 (21)

4.73*

  1. *p < .05 **p < .01 ***p < .001.