Skip to main content

Table 6 Moderator analysis for school level and program intensity for studies reporting continuous and categorical measures

From: Effectiveness of school-based preventive interventions on adolescent alcohol use: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

 

Studies reporting continuous measures

Studies reporting categorical measures

k

g ¯

95% CI

Q

df

I 2

Total between Q

k

OR ¯

95% CI

Q

df

I 2

Total between Q

School level:

      

0.80

      

0.00

  Junior high school

7

0.12***

0.05-0.19

14.41*

6

58.42%

 

8

0.91

0.77-1.07

25.24***

7

72.26%

 

  High school

4

0.35

− 0.15-0.85

143.91***

3

92.92%

 

4

0.91

0.80-1.03

2.93

3

0.00%

 

Program intensity:

      

0.07

      

0.09

  Medium (6 to 10 hours)

7

0.23

− 0.00-0.46

180.11***

6

96.67%

 

3

0.90

0.76-1.07

0.47

2

0.00%

 

  High (11 to >15 hours)

3

0.20***

0.13-0.26

1.34

2

0.00%

 

12

0.93

0.82-1.06

36.16***

11

69.58%

 
  1. Note. Mixed effect analysis. k = number of studies; g ¯ = mean Hedges’g; OR ¯ = mean Odds Ratio; 95% CI = 95% confidence interval; Q = test of heterogeneity; df = degrees of freedom; I2 = proportion of observed dispersion. *p < .05 **p < .01 ***p < .001.